data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0f846/0f846cc4a8711e3b52fbc82904baf9a4bd7662ce" alt="'Greetings. I am the WATCHER. And I am here to PUMP YOU UP.'"
from What If? (1977 series) #14 (Marvel, April 1979), script by Don Glut, pencils by Herb Trimpe, inks by Pablo Marcos, colors by "D. R. Martin", letters by Tom Orzechowski
Yes, it's the infamous issue of What If? that gives us SGT. FURY IN SPAAAAAAACE(aaaace aaaace aaaace)!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8d579/8d579bdc8205b8dad9759e8cd0ac04bfe4465b42" alt="First Star Wars, then Battlestar Galactica, then more Star Wars for a few years, then more Star Wars, then at last some more battlestar Galactica, then some more Star Wars until the end of time."
cover of What If? #14; pencils by Herb Trimpe, inks by Joe Sinnott, letters by Gaspar Saladino
What the--? How the Sam Scratch (or Sam Sawyer) can an outer space battle be taking place in 194-flippin-1? Well, here's the first reason: Because Leonardo DaVinci.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/298bf/298bfa4fac45ee240604752872fcebdf7e0f8b4c" alt="The irony is that now the Marvel U has revelaed da Vinci was one of the founders of SHIELD, this all kinda makes sense."
This is regarded as something of a cheat among is What If?fiandos, because What Ifs are generally defined as revolving around a changed point specific to the Marvel Universe, not general history. But let's just blame the Watcher™ for this one. or should we blame reason number 2?...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/fd1bd/fd1bdc63401ff79d7160359c0c07707dfd67e9de" alt="That concept is doin' a WHOLE lotta heavy lifting just to put Fury in a space helmet, I'm tellin' ya."
Reason #2: Roy Thomas, who invented "What If."! Rioy' editorship of this still-fairly-new title has never let a violation of the basic concept get in the way of an entertaining story. Still, not every fan bought "da Vinci created technology earlier" as an excuse to twist a tale around, including me...but then I saw the final sentence of Roy's reply.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/dd076/dd076d48d461c2f768efb98575f932fb565946fa" alt="'Also, they hate that you gave a role to a woman.'"
from the letter column in What If? #16 (Marvel, August 1979)
You're saying comics oughta be fun, Roy?!?
You have hoisted me on my own petard, Rascally One! I mean, just lookit this space war action! That warrants a big wow! In spaaaaaaace!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/fe6fb/fe6fbb9d4073892d48a0f3d8e204a27864c69a49" alt="Outfit from the Magneto COllection of Beverly Hills."
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6c360/6c360b55bfa47519208ae10adc1f481ad0bdb2ad" alt="They had to paint those arrows on the ships so they'd know which way to go."
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/57f64/57f647ead7be611b6529cb1f7754aac948ea5ed4" alt="So in this universe, terrible racist comic book portrayals of the Japanese didn't exist? Thanks, comic book!"
Anyway, my point (and I do have one) is that this here comicy book covers the Battle of Midway! IN SPAAAAAAACE(aaaace aaaace aaaace)! So if December 7, 1941 is the date on which Space Station Pearl was attacked, that mean this here story takes place when the real Midway started: June 4, 1942! In SPAAAoh you know the rest.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d9872/d98729b3d3b4695055b93ce0f38f0eeeef07b37b" alt="Yes, they are almost 700 years ahead of our technical culture, yet Fury still carries around a manual can opener....SCIENCE!"
Well, it's better than the movie Midway, I'll tell ya that. The new one...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1197f/1197f5e8683d58d78588bceb6301424b9da6e3d0" alt="'Near...far...where EVER you are...'"
...or the old one.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/42c0f/42c0f6e67e6332926987987487bf80116c433920" alt="Senssurround! Where all we do is turn up the bass on the speakers REALLY LOUD! And charge you five bucks more."
Now, this comic doesn't have Sensurround, but it does have Sgt. Fury smoking his cigar inside a space helmet, and that's better than a movie any day.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/17df9/17df9ed69e3aeca9f141a0e6275b55026240d1b4" alt="'PEACE OUT, MAH BRAHS!'"
So if that story took place on June 4, there's no reason this story, teased at the end of What If? #14, can't take place tomorrow (in Comics History) on June 5! Right? Right!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1a569/1a569d21945f3cc092aac36164a2cd251e3d7839" alt="The Beatles? The Monkees? The...uh, I can't think of any more groups of four people in the Marvel Universe."
PS: That story does not take place tomorrow.
2 comments:
I didn't pick this up off the racks despite very much enjoying most issues of the series because Li'l Blam was all about the superheroes and not so much with secret agents, war, or even general outer-space adventure, despite loving Star Wars in theaters. Anyway, my point, and I do have one, is that I think you mixed up the hover-text for the splash page and cover that lead off the post.
Yikes! Thanks, Blam! Fixed now.
Post a Comment